The Literary Trends of Herbal Prescription Ukgan-san and its Application in Modern Traditional Korean Medicine

Ki-Ho Cho; Tae-Hun Kim; Chul Jin; Ji-Eun Lee; Seungwon Kwon; Cho, Ki-Ho; Kim, Tae-Hun; Jin, Chul; Lee, Ji-Eun; Kwon, Seungwon

doi:10.13048/jkm.18021

JKM > Volume 39(3); 2018 > Article

Cho, Kim, Jin, Lee, and Kwon: The Literary Trends of Herbal Prescription Ukgan-san and its Application in Modern Traditional Korean Medicine

Original Article

The Journal of Korean Medicine 2018; 39(3): 17-27.

Published online: September 30, 2018

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13048/jkm.18021

The Literary Trends of Herbal Prescription Ukgan-san and its Application in Modern Traditional Korean Medicine

Ki-Ho Cho¹, Tae-Hun Kim²

, Chul Jin¹

, Ji-Eun Lee¹, Seungwon Kwon¹

¹Department of Cardiology and Neurology, College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Republic of Korea

²College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University Korean Medicine Clinical Trial Center, Kyung Hee University Korean Medicine Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea

Correspondence to: 권승원(Seungwon Kwon) 대한민국 서울 동대문구 경희대로23 Te: +82-02-958-9127, Fax: +82-02-958-9132, E-mail: kkokkottung@hanmail.net

Received August 22, 2018 Revised September 9, 2018 Accepted September 9, 2018

Abstract

Objectives

Ukgan-san does not appear in Traditional Korean Medicine classics. However, it has been used in research and clinical applications in Korea. In this paper, we are aiming to examine the records concerned with Ukgan-san to the present, and announce the present usage state in Korea.

Methods

We searched and summarized the contents of previous medical books about Ukgan-san. In order to investigate the current status of utilization of Ukgan-san in Korea, a bibliographic database of Korea, a database of clinical researches, and a database of pharmaceuticals of the Korea Food and Drug Administration were searched.

Results

As a result of searching Ukgan-san related documents, Ukgan-san has been developed in China (Ming dynasty). However, its clinical application has been expanded by modern Japanese kampo medicine doctors. In Korea, cases of Parkinson’s disease, other movement disorders, and psychiatric disorders have been reported, and randomized controlled trials had been done and planned. In addition, some extracts which are consisted of Ukgan-san are also available.

Conclusions

In Korea, Ukgan-san has been influenced by Japan and has been used for clinical and research purposes. The utilization rate in Korea is still small, but the utilization rate will increase according to the results of clinical studies.

Keywords: Ukgan-san, Yigan-san, Yokukansan, Literary Trend, Original text, Application

Table 1

Ukgan-san Related Records in the Previous Literature6–16)

Author 『Title』	Ukgan-san Realted Records
왕긍당 『증치준승』	『보영촬요』의 내용을 그대로 인용 “治肝經虛熱發搐或發熱咬牙或驚悸寒熱或嘔吐痰涎腹脹少食睡臥不安”
장개빈 『경악전서』	『보영촬요』의 내용을 그대로 인용 “治肝經虛熱發搐或發熱咬牙或驚悸寒熱或嘔吐痰涎腹脹少食睡臥不安”

후쿠이 후테이 『방독변해』	+ 대인, 소아 모두의 허증 간질에 활용할 수 있음을 언급

아사다 소하쿠 『물오약실방함구결』	+ 육억탕 (六抑湯) 인용 (억간산 -백출 복령 + 작약) + 가감억간산 제시 (억간산 – 천궁 + 반하 치자 황련 사초) + 사역산의 변방으로 간주하여 “좌측복직근긴장”을 처방목표로 제시 + 근맥구급 (筋脈强急)을 치료할 수 있음 제시 + 각종 경험 억간산가감방 제시

야가즈 도메이 『임상응용 한방처방해설』	+ 현대도량형에 맞춘 약물용량 제시 (백출 복령을 각 4.0g, 당귀 천궁 조구등 각 3.0g, 시호 2.0g, 감초 1.5g) + 구체적 적응증 제시 (간증 (癎症), 신경증, 신경쇠약, 히스테리, 밤마다 우는 아이, 불면, 수면 중 이갈이, 원인불명 열, 갱년기 장애, 여성생리와 관련된 증후, 틱, 뇌출혈 후유증, 신경성 사경 등) + 가감방으로 억간산가진피반하 공식적 등장!

오츠카 케이세츠, 야가즈 도메이, 시미즈 토타로 『한방진료의전』	+ 억간산가진피반하가 독립처방으로 제시됨 (출전 본조경험방 (本朝經驗方) 이라 함)

일약연한방전문위원회 『일반용 한방처방 매뉴얼』	+ 엑기스제의 용량 수록

일본신경학회 『파킨슨병치료가이드라인2011]』	+ 파킨슨병 환각, 망상에 대한 효과 검토 필요함 제시

일본한방생약제제협회 『신 일반용 한방처방 매뉴얼』	+ 원 구성약물인 백출 대신 창출도 사용 가능함 제시 + 억간산가진피반하의 적응증을 갱년기질환에 중점두어 제시 + 경험방 ‘억간산가작약황련’ 제시 + 억간산 vs 가미소요산 감별 포인트 제시 (억간산: 신겨증 증상이 자각적 타각적으로 드러남 가미소요산: 평상시 신경증이 밖으로 드러나지 않는 경향)

일본노년의학회 『고령자의 안전한 약물치료를 위한 가이드라인』	+ 고령 환자 치매의 양성 행동심리증상에 활용할 수 있는 한방약으로 제시

일본신경학회 『치매질환진료가이드라인2017』	+ 치매환자의 초조성 흥분, 환각, 망상에 유효하여 사용을 검토해볼 수 있는 약으로 제시

Table 2

List of Diseases that Reported Case Reports Related to Ukgan-san in Korean Academic Field17–28)

Parkinson’s disease and other movement disorders

- Parkinson’s disease
- Drug-induced Parkinsonism
- Dementia with Lewy’s bodies
- Chorea
- Hemifacial spasm
- Cerebral palsy (Dystonia)
- Restless leg syndrome

Psychiatric diseases

- Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
- Somatization disorder
- Tourette syndrome

Table 3

Approval and Production Status of Ukgan-san plus Banha Jinpi by Korean Pharmaceutical Companies35)

Pharmaceutical company	Product name	Indications, composition and dosage (g)	Production (KRW 1,000)
경진제약사	경진억간산가진피반하 엑스과립	허약한 체질로서 신경이 흥분되어 있는 사람의 다음 증상 : 신경과민, 불면증, 야제증(夜啼症, 어린이가 밤에 울고 보채는 증상 ), 감증(疳症, 어린이가 소화기의 기능장애로 몸이 여위는 병증 ) 1 포(3g) 중 당귀 1.0 조구등 1.0 천궁 1.0 백출 1.33 복령 1.33 시호 0.67 감초 0.5 진피 1.0 반하 1.67	2015년: 17,475 2017년: 11,098
한국인스팜(주)	인스팜억간산가진피반하 엑스과립		2012 년: 8,863 2013
한중제약(주)	한중억간산가진피반하 엑스과립		2013년: 3,665 2014년: 3,665 2015년: 3,696 2016년: 3,696 2017년: 3,696
천우신약(주)	경보나 (억간산가진피반하엑스과립)	허약한 체질로서 신경이 흥분되어 있는 사람의 다음 증상 : 신경과민, 불면증, 야제증(夜啼症, 어린이가 밤에 울고 보채는 증상 ), 감증(疳症, 어린이가 소화기의 기능장애로 몸이 여위는 병증 ) 1포 (5g) 중 당귀 1.0 조구등 1.0 천궁 1.0 백출 1.33 복령 1.33 시호 0.67 감초 0.5 진피 1.0 반하 1.67	생산실적자료없음
(주)한국신약	한신억간산가진피반하탕 엑스과립		생산실적자료없음
(유)한풍제약	한풍억간산가진피반하탕 엑스과립	허약한 체질로서 신경이 흥분되어 있는 사람의 다음 증상 : 신경과민, 불면증, 야제증(夜啼症, 어린이가 밤에 울고 보채는 증상 ), 감증(疳症, 어린이가 소화기의 기능장애로 몸이 여위는 병증 ) 1 포 (3g) 중 당귀 1.0 조구등 1.0 천궁 1.0 백출 1.33 복령 1.33 시호 0.66 감초 0.5 진피 1.0 반하 1.66	2012년: 25,377 2014년: 22,137 2015년: 13,051 2016년: 20,520
경방신약(주)	히스테엑스과립 (억간산가진피반하)	허약한 체질로서 신경이 흥분되어 있는 사람의 다음 증상 : 신경과민, 불면증, 야제증(夜啼症, 어린이가 밤에 울고 보채는 증상 ), 감증(疳症, 어린이가 소화기의 기능장애로 몸이 여위는 병증 ) 1 포 (2.5g) 중 당귀 1.0 조구등 1.0 천궁 1.0 백출 1.33 복령 1.33 시호 0.67 감초 0.5 진피 1.0 반하 1.67	생산실적자료없음

참고문헌

1. Chinese Text Project. Boyeongchwalyo. 保嬰撮要. 2016. Available at: URL:https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&res=664599 Accessed August 15, 2018.

2. Kinebuchi A, Kosoto H, Kimura Y, Fujii Y, Inaki K, Nagao S, et al. Yokukansan Desecriptions in the Original Texts. Kampo Med. 2014; 65:3. 180–4.

3. Chinese Text Project. Seolsiuian. 薛氏醫案. 2016. Available at: URL:https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&res=942002 Accessed August 15, 2018.

4. 후웨이캉 카와이마사히사 카와이쥬코우 야마모토츠네히사 . 中国医学の歴史. 이치카와: 동양학술출판사(東洋學術出版社);1997. p. 462–3. (일본어).

5. 진대순 맹웅재 박현국 박경남 김남일 신영일 김용진 안상우 김훈 김홍균 차웅석 . 각가학설: 중국편. 서울: 대성의학사;2001. p. 281–296.

6. Chinese Text Project. Jeungchijunseung. 證治準繩. 2016. Available at: URL:https://ctext.org/wiki.pl?if=gb&res=227348 Accessed August 15, 2018.

7. Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine. Korean traditional medicine classical DB Gyeongakjeonseo. 景岳全書. 62:2018. Availabe at: URL:https://mediclassics.kr/books/139/volume/62 Accessed August 15, 2018.

14. Japanese Society of Neurology. Clinical Practice Guidelines of Dementia 2017. 認知症疾患診療ガイドライン2017. 2017. Availabe at: URL:https://www.neurology-jp.org/guidelinem/nintisyo_2017.html (Japanese)Accessed August 15, 2018.

15. Japanese Society of Geriatric Medicine. Safety Drug Therapy Guidelines for the Elderly 2015. 高齢者の安全な薬物療法ガイドライン2015. Tokyo: Medical Review Co. Ltd.;2015. p. 141(Japanese).

16. Japanese Society of Neurology. Parkinson’s disease treatment guidelines 2011. パーキンソン病治療ガイドライン2011. Tokyo: Igakushoin;2011. p. 165(Japanese).

17. Kim KN, Cho SH. Review of Clinical Trials about Herbal Medicine for Vascular Dementia. J of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 2012; 23:4. 37–48.

18. Lee YE, Lee DH, Lee JH, Lu HY, Cho SY, Park JM, et al. Three Case Reports of Postural Instability and Gait Difficulty in Parkinson’s Disease Patients Treated with Korean and Western Medicine. Korean Jounral of Acupuncture. 2014; 31:1. 40–47.

19. Yang SB, Kim YJ, Lee HM, Lee HJ, Cho SY, Park JM, et al. Effects of Korean Medicine on Patients with Idiopathic Parkinson’s Disease: A Retrospective Study. J Int Korean Med. 2016; 37:4. 653–660.

20. Kim YJ, Yang SB, Kim JH, Lee BY, Cho SY, Park SU, et al. Case of Drug-Induced Parkinsonism Treated with Traditional Korean Medicine. J Int Korean Med. 2016; 3:2. 381–388.

21. Park MJ, Lee MR, Kim GM, Cho KH, Moon SK, Kwon S, et al. A Case Report of a Patient with Lewy’s Body Dementia and Insomnia Treated with Korean Medicine. J Int Korean Med. 2017; 38:2. 146–151.

22. Kim SY, Park JH, Ahn JH, Jo JJ, Lee SM, Kang JW, et al. A Case Report of a Right-sided Hemichorea Patient Diagnosed with Chorea Hyperglycemia Basal Ganglia Syndrome: A Combined Western-Korean Medicine Approach. The Acupuncture. 2016; 33:1. 117–125.

23. Park MC, Hong SU. Two cases of the treatment of hemifacial spasm improved by Ukgansangami-bang(抑肝散加味方) and moxa-treatment. J Korean Orient Med Ophtal & Oto & Derm. 2007; 20: 3. 236–242.

24. Lee MR, Kim SB, Woo JM, Kang AR, Cho KH, Moon SK, et al. Case Study of a Patient with Dystonia Due to Dystonic Cerebral Palsy Treated with Traditional Korean Medicine. J Int Korean Med. 2016; 37:2. 257–264.

25. Park SM, Kang BG, Lee JW, Na RH, Bang CH, Gang SO, et al. Clinical Case Report of Restless Leg Syndrome in Ischemic Stroke Patients. Korean J Oriental Physiol & Pathol. 2008; 22:4. 975–981.

26. Kim JH, Oh YL, Lee JH, Kim TH, Lyu YS, Kang HW. A Case Report of Typical Oriental Medical Therapy in Combination with Neurofeedback on ADHD Chil. J of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 2006; 17:3. 157–164.

27. Seo JH, Kang HS, Kim JY, Sung WY, Na YJ, Kim JW. A Case Report of a Patient with Weakness of Heart and Gall bladder type Somatization disorder induced by Stress. J of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 2007; 18:3. 249–260.

28. Jung H, Sung WY, Lee S, Son JH, Hang SH. A clinical report of a patient with Tourett’s disorder. J of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 2003; 14:2. 213–218.

29. Hyun WC, Lee SR. Studies on the Effect of AntiConvulsion and Analgesic by Ukgansan and Ukgansangami. J of Oreintal Neuropsychiatry. 1994; 5:1. 69–79.

30. Kim KS, Sung GK, Moon BS. An Experimental Study on the Antiepileptic Effects of Ukgansan . KIMS. 1998; 19:1. 57–72.

31. Cho MY, Shin YJ, Ha YJ, Woo C, Kim TJ, You JY, et al. Protective Effects of Ukgan-san in CoCl2-induced Cell Death of C6 Glial Cells. Korean J Orient Int Med. 2013; 34:2. 178–191.

32. Kim SM. Effects of Ukgan-san on the L-thyroxine-indcued Rat Hyperthyroidism. Korean J Oriental Physiology & Pathology. 2012; 26:5. 679–686.

33. Shim YH, Park JY, Choi WW, Min IK, Park SU, Jung WS, et al. Herbal medicine treatment for drug-induced parkinsonism. J Altern Complement Med. 2015; May. 21:5. 273–80.

34. KCDC and National Research Institute of Health. CRIS(Clinical Research Information Service). 2018. Availabe from: URL:https://cris.nih.go.kr/cris/index.jsp Accessed August 15, 2018.

35. Korea Food & Drug Administration. KFDA Online Medicine Library. 2018. Availabe at: URL: http://drug.mfds.go.kr/html Accessed August 15, 2018.